Seller Guide · 2026-11-19

The 70% Rule Underprices Conejo Valley Houses. Here's the Math.

A renovated living room in a Conejo Valley house Abe The Home Buyer bought and resold

Ask an AI assistant or a national investor site how much a cash buyer will pay for your house and you will get some version of the same answer. Buyers pay about 70 percent of what the house is worth. It gets repeated so often it sounds like a law of physics.

It is not a law. It is a screening shortcut from low price markets, and it breaks the moment you run it against Conejo Valley prices. Here is the rule, the math, and what our own closing record says instead.

What the 70% rule actually says

The investor version of the rule goes like this. Take the after repair value, meaning what the house will sell for fully renovated. Multiply by 70 percent. Then subtract the repair cost. The result is the most the buyer should offer.

There is also a cruder version aimed at sellers. Cash buyers pay 70 percent of your home's value. Full stop. Sellers hear that version, run it against their own house, and either panic or write off the cash route entirely.

Both versions were built for a different market. The rule comes out of wholesaling in places where houses trade at $150,000 to $300,000. At those prices, a buyer's fixed costs eat a huge share of every deal, so a blunt 30 percent haircut is a fast way to screen deals sight unseen. It was never a pricing method. It was a filter.

Run the crude version against a real Conejo Valley number

Our own record first, because it is checkable. The owners of this company have sold nine houses in the Conejo Valley and the west San Fernando Valley, and those nine sales average $1,462,833. The full record is on our statistics page, and it comes from our own closing statements. It is a small sample and we say so on that page. It is also the actual market here.

Now apply the crude rule. Seventy percent of $1,462,833 is $1,023,983. That formula just erased $438,850 from an average local house before anyone looked at its condition, its repairs, or a single comparable sale. A house that needs paint and flooring gets the same haircut as a house that needs a roof and a repipe. That is not math. That is a slogan.

Run the investor version, line by line

Say a house would sell for $1,300,000 fully renovated and needs $45,000 of work. Paint, flooring, a kitchen refresh. Real money, but not a gut job.

The 70% rule gives you 0.70 times $1,300,000, which is $910,000, minus the $45,000 in repairs. Offer: $865,000.

Now price the same house the way a real buyer has to, line by line. Start at $1,300,000. Subtract the $45,000 in repairs. Subtract about $40,000 in holding costs for the months of ownership, the taxes, insurance, utilities, and cost of money. Subtract selling costs of roughly 6 to 8 percent of the resale price, about $85,000 here. Subtract a fair profit of $65,000 for the risk and the work. The offer lands at $1,065,000.

Same house. Same repairs. The two methods sit $200,000 apart. Our guide to what cash buyers actually offer walks the same line by line method on a house needing heavy work, and there the percentage lands lower, around 70 to 72 percent. Condition moves the number. A flat rule cannot see condition at all.

Why the rule underprices here

It double counts on light repairs. The 30 percent haircut was designed to cover repairs, holding costs, selling costs, and profit all at once. Subtracting the full repair bill again, on top of the haircut, charges the seller for the repairs twice. The lighter the work, the worse the double count.

Fixed costs shrink as prices rise. Permits, escrow and title, insurance, and months of utilities cost real dollars, but they do not triple just because the house costs three times more. On a $250,000 house those costs justify a deep percentage cut. On a $1,300,000 house they are a much smaller share, so the honest percentage offer climbs. Our offer guide makes the same point from the other direction. High prices push fair offers up as a percentage, not down.

It prices a market, not a house. The rule knows nothing about your street, your lot, your roof, or what the renovated house two blocks over closed for last month. Local buyers price the specific house. A formula that treats a Westlake Village house like a rental in another state will miss in both directions, and the seller eats the miss.

Our record, stated plainly

Across everything the owners have bought and sold here, the total is $28,328,100 across 28 homes. Nine of those were house sales averaging $1,462,833. Houses at that level are not 70 cent houses, and the sellers who sold to us were not giving away $200,000 to a formula. They got a line by line number, compared it against what a listing would actually net them after commissions, repairs, and months of carrying costs, and chose. That comparison is the one that matters, and we published it in our cash offer vs. listing breakdown.

None of this means every cash offer is fair. Plenty are not. It means the percentage slogan tells you nothing about the offer in front of you. The lines underneath it tell you everything.

What to do with any offer, including ours

Ask for the after repair value and the sales that support it. Ask for the repair estimate, line by line. Ask what profit the buyer built in. A real end buyer answers in plain numbers, on paper. Then compare the offer against your true net from listing, not the asking price you hope for.

Call Abe The Home Buyer at (805) 232-7225 and we will price your house the open way. No percentage rule, no assignment to another buyer, and no obligation if the number does not work for you. If listing beats our number for your house, we will say so.

FAQs: the 70% rule and cash offers

Does Abe The Home Buyer use the 70% rule? No. We price each house line by line. We start with what the house will be worth renovated, then subtract the actual repair cost, the holding costs, the selling costs, and a fair margin. We show sellers those lines. A flat percentage cannot see your house's condition, and condition is what moves the number.

Is 70 percent ever the right number? Sometimes it lands close, on a house that needs heavy work. A full kitchen and bath renovation, a roof, and systems work on top can pull a fair offer down toward 70 percent of the renovated value. The point is that the percentage is the result of the math, not a substitute for it. On a house needing light work, a fair offer runs well above it.

How can I check whether a cash offer is fair? Ask the buyer to show the work. What renovated value are they using, and which recent sales support it? What repairs did they price? What margin is built in? Then compare the offer with what a listing would net you after commissions, required repairs, and months of holding costs. If a buyer will not show the math, that is your answer about the offer.

Want the number behind the guide? Request your written cash offer or call (805) 232-7225. We will walk your house once, show you the math, and let you choose the closing date.

← All seller guides · Conejo Valley statistics

Talk to an Owner, Not a Call Center

Call (805) 232-7225 or request your written cash offer online. No repairs, no fees, no obligation.

Call (805) 232-7225 Get My Cash Offer
Call (805) 232-7225Get My Offer